FDIC Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

2024

i i

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Table of Contents

Overview ................................................................................................................................................. 1

Introduction ............................................................................................................................................ 5

State of Economic Inclusion in the United States ...................................................................................... 7

Application of Learning from the Environmental Scan ............................................................................ 14

Implementation of the Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan ...................................................................... 17

Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan Framework ....................................................................................... 18

Opportunity Area 1. Create and Sustain Foundational Banking Relationships: Establish an on-

ramp to the U.S. financial system, setting the stage for future financial success. ............................... 19

Motivation ..................................................................................................................................................... 19

Theory of Change .......................................................................................................................................... 21

Strategies ...................................................................................................................................................... 22

Key Performance Indicators .......................................................................................................................... 23

Opportunity Area 2. Build Household Financial Stability: Help households save and increase

access to consumer credit to better manage ongoing and emergency expenses ................................. 25

Motivation ..................................................................................................................................................... 25

Theory of Change .......................................................................................................................................... 27

Strategies ...................................................................................................................................................... 28

Key Performance Indicators .......................................................................................................................... 29

Opportunity Area 3. Achieve a Secure Financial Future: Build household wealth through

investments that can foster savings and accumulate value over time. ............................................... 31

Motivation ..................................................................................................................................................... 31

Theory of Change .......................................................................................................................................... 34

Strategies ...................................................................................................................................................... 35

Key Performance Indicators .......................................................................................................................... 37

Opportunity Area 4. Live in Strong and Healthy Communities: Encourage bank lending,

investments, and services that support strong and healthy communities, including low- and

moderate-income (LMI) neighborhoods and other underserved communities ................................... 38

Motivation ..................................................................................................................................................... 38

Theory of Change .......................................................................................................................................... 40

Strategies ...................................................................................................................................................... 41

Key Performance Indicators .......................................................................................................................... 42

Appendices ............................................................................................................................................ 43

Appendix A: Overview of Environmental Scan Process ..................................................................... A-1

Appendix B: Research Questions and Associated Literature Sources from the Environmental

Scan ............................................................................................................................................... B-1

ii ii

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Exhibits

Figure 1. Economic Inclusion Opportunity Areas .................................................................................... 2

Figure 2. Key Terms Used in the Plan ...................................................................................................... 3

Figure 3. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 1: Create and Sustain Foundational Banking

Relationships ........................................................................................................................................ 21

Figure 4. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 2: Build Household Financial Stability...................... 27

Figure 5. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 3: Achieve a Secure Financial Future ........................ 34

Figure 6. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 4: Live in Strong and Healthy Communities ............. 40

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Overview

The FDIC published its first Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan (Plan) in 2014. Since then, the number of

unbanked households has reached the lowest level since the FDIC began collecting the data in 2008,

and both consumers’ needs and the market for financial services have evolved. This Plan updates the

FDIC strategy to promote economic inclusion in light of these changes. The Plan is designed to support

progress toward a state in which all U.S. households can establish, sustain, and benefit from banking

relationships to create a strong financial foundation, manage their day-to-day finances, build wealth,

and live in communities strengthened by bank lending, services, and investments.

To better respond to the current environment and the opportunities to advance economic inclusion,

the FDIC has organized its Plan around four Economic Inclusion Opportunity Areas (Opportunity Areas)

that emphasize consumer and community outcomes. These Opportunity Areas—identified and

illustrated in Figure 1 below—will guide the FDIC’s eﬀorts to capitalize on emerging opportunities and

eﬀectively address identified challenges to economic inclusion. The Plan provides a flexible roadmap

for how the FDIC will direct its eﬀorts and resources to promote economic inclusion for all U.S.

households.

This Plan was informed by an environmental scan comprising a literature review of more than 70

sources, including peer-reviewed articles, white papers, and FDIC internal documents, plus interviews

with more than 50 internal and external stakeholders. (Details on the environmental scan process and

the literature review are included in Appendices A and B.) Findings from the environmental scan

generated insights into the state of economic inclusion in the United States, including both challenges

and emerging opportunities. These findings informed the formulation of the Opportunity Areas,

objectives, and strategies of the Plan.

This Plan begins with a short introduction, followed by a description of key findings from the

environmental scan. It then describes each of the four Opportunity Areas. For each Opportunity Area,

the Plan lays out a clear objective, monitoring measures, strategies, and key performance indicators.

Figure 2 below defines key terms used throughout the Plan.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Figure 1. Economic Inclusion Opportunity Areas

Goal: Promote economic inclusion for all U.S. households

Vision: The FDIC supports economic inclusion by promoting a state in which all U.S. households can

establish, sustain, and benefit from banking relationships to create a strong financial foundation, manage

their day-to-day finances, build wealth, and live in communities strengthened by bank lending, services,

and investments.

Economic Inclusion Opportunity Areas:

1. Create and Sustain Foundational Banking Relationships: Establish an on-ramp to the U.S. financial

system, setting the stage for future financial success.

2. Build Household Financial Stability: Help households save and increase access to consumer credit

to better manage ongoing and emergency expenses.

3. Achieve a Secure Financial Future: Build household wealth through investments that can foster

savings and accumulate value over time.

4. Live in Strong and Healthy Communities: Encourage bank lending, investments, and services that

support strong and healthy communities, including low- and moderate-income (LMI) neighborhoods

and other underserved communities.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Figure 2. Key Terms Used in the Plan

Banks: Insured depository institutions that the FDIC intends to engage with to foster economic inclusion.

Bankable moments: Events or points in time when a consumer has an increase or change in their regular,

day-to-day cash flow, such as when receiving benefits or starting a new job. These moments are an

opportunity for consumers who are unbanked to find and open a bank account that meets their needs.

Economic inclusion: A state in which all U.S. consumers and communities have access to financial services,

secure employment, and opportunities to participate in the broader economy. The FDIC’s economic

inclusion activities aim to ensure that all U.S. households can access, sustainably use, and increasingly

benefit from safe and aﬀordable products and services from insured depository institutions.

Impact:

The broader changes that occur in a community, an organization, or society because of program

outcomes.

Key performance indicators (KPIs): Measures of FDIC activity used to track contributions toward achieving

each objective. These measures reflect outputs and outcomes resulting from the implementation of the

strategies outlined in the Plan. As necessary, the FDIC might adjust these measures based on available data

or use estimated quantities. These measures might be updated to reflect specific economic inclusion

activities that the FDIC engages in. For key performance indicators with a market share component, the

FDIC will try to measure the extent to which underserved populations are being reached.

Low- and moderate-income communities: A low-income community means median family income is less

than 50 percent of the area median income. A moderate-income community means median family income is

at least 50 percent and less than 80 percent of the area median income.

Low- and moderate-income individuals/households: An individual or household is considered to be low-

or moderate-income based on how their income compares to the area median income. A low-income

individual or household has an income that is less than 50 percent of the area median income. A moderate-

income individual or household has an income that is at least 50 percent and less than 80 percent of the area

median income.

Market share: A relative measure of a firm’s activity, which can be expressed in various terms, including the

share of a particular product or activity provided by the firm among all other firms or a subset of relevant

firms or the proportion of total potential customers served or otherwise connected to a firm or to a product

or service from a firm.

Monitoring measures: Metrics the FDIC will use to track overall progress toward each objective, to

understand trends in economic conditions, and to provide context for assessing program outcomes. The

FDIC will monitor the trends for each of these indicators, even as it recognizes that its work is not solely

responsible for changes in these measures. The FDIC may substitute monitoring measures for various

reasons, such as instances in which data that provide more precise, more accurate, or qualitatively better

information relevant to an opportunity area become available.

Objective: A statement of the impact that the FDIC seeks to advance through its work.

Opportunity Area: Broad categories in which the FDIC plans to work to advance economic inclusion in the

banking system. Each Opportunity Area is accompanied by a brief description of the FDIC’s vision for that

Area.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

The term “insured depository institution” has a specific regulatory definition that can be found in the Federal

Deposit Insurance Act, and includes banks and savings associations.

Regulation B, which implements the Equal Credit Opportunity Act, sets forth compliance standards and

general rules for Special Purpose Credit programs [15 U.S.C. § 1691(c)(1)-(3); 12 C.F.R. § 1002.8(a)].

The 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households refers to “single-mother

households” as a subset of unmarried female-householder family households. The survey found single-

mother households had an unbanked rate of 16 percent; single-father households had a similarly high

unbanked rate of 11 percent. This Plan uses the term “single-parent households” to group these household

types under one term.

Outcome: The result of a program’s outputs. Evaluating outcomes answers the question, “Are the

participants achieving intended results?”

Outputs: The quantifiable results produced as a direct consequence of program activities and eﬀorts, oen

serving as a tool for monitoring initial progress toward achieving program outcomes.

Partnerships: Collaborative eﬀorts in which the FDIC works closely with federal, state, and local

government agencies; community-based organizations; financial institutions; or others on specific eﬀorts

such as programs or initiatives.

Special Purpose Credit program: A targeted lending program designed to meet the credit needs of an

economically disadvantaged group of borrowers. The primary aim of a Special Purpose Credit program

to provide access to credit and financial support in which traditional lending options are limited or

insuﬀicient.

Stakeholders: Federal, local, and state government oﬀices; banks; and community-based organizations

that the FDIC collaborates with on events and/or that participate in events.

Strategy: An overarching approach or type of activity designed to help achieve the objectives in the Plan.

Over time, these activities and the resources allocated to them might be adjusted to reflect emerging

opportunities to promote economic inclusion.

Unbanked: Households in which no one has a checking or savings account at a bank or credit union.

Underbanked: Households that were banked and in the past 12 months used at least one nonbank

transaction (money orders, check cashing, or international remittances) or nonbank credit (rent-to-own

services, payday, pawn shop, tax refund anticipation or auto title loans) product or service that is

disproportionately used by unbanked households to meet basic financial needs.

Underserved consumers/households/communities: Groups that are disproportionately unbanked and

underbanked. These groups include, but are not limited to, lower-income households, less-educated

households, Black households, Hispanic households, working-age households with a disability, and single-

parent households.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Introduction

Congress created the FDIC through the

Banking Act of 1933 to maintain stability and

public confidence in the nation’s banking

system. The statute provides a federal

government guarantee of deposits so that

customer funds will be safe and available to

them in the event of bank failures.

The FDIC acts as receiver for banks that fail,

and it has resolution planning

responsibilities for large, complex financial

institutions. In addition to its role as insurer,

the FDIC is the primary federal regulator of

federally insured state-chartered banks that

are not members of the Federal Reserve

System.

An important component of maintaining

stability and public confidence in the banking

system is promoting economic inclusion, and

in so doing, demonstrating that the banking

system is a resource that can benefit

everyone. For the FDIC, this means engaging

in strategies and programs designed to

expand access to safe, secure, and aﬀordable

financial products and services from banks

for all consumers to help them meet their

financial needs and goals.

The FDIC recognizes that special eﬀorts are

needed to ensure expanded access to

financial services for low- and moderate-

income (LMI) consumers, consumers of color,

and other underserved groups such as households led by working-age individuals with a disability,

single-parent households, and consumers with fewer years of formal education. Promoting economic

inclusion among these populations requires understanding their financial needs and challenges,

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2022–2026 Strategic Plan (December 2021).

LMI households and households of color are

more likely than other households to be

unbanked and underbanked

The 2024 Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan aims to

broaden access to financial services for all consumers,

but especially for consumers who have been

historically underserved by the banking system,

including low- and moderate-income (LMI) households

and people of color.

According to the 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked

and Underbanked Households (2021 FDIC Household

Survey), these groups were much less likely than their

peers to have a bank account:

• About one in five households earning less than

$15,000 per year were unbanked; in comparison,

fewer than one in 100 households earning more than

$75,000 per year were unbanked.

• Black households were more than five times as likely

to be unbanked as White households, and Hispanic

households were more than four times as likely to be

unbanked as White households.

• Working-age households with a disability were also

disproportionately unbanked—four times the rate of

such households without a disability.

• LMI households and households of color with a bank

account were more likely to be underbanked.

The Plan notes diﬀerences in outcomes that are more

likely to be experienced by underserved groups that

participate in the mainstream banking system and

identifies the underserved as populations that should

be specifically considered.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

encouraging the development of products and services that meet those needs, and leveraging

partnerships and additional strategies for successfully delivering them to consumers.

Over the past decade, the FDIC has generated a series of strategic planning documents to guide its

economic inclusion eﬀorts. The Chairman’s Advisory Committee on Economic Inclusion (ComE-IN)

developed the first strategic plan in 2006 to guide its work.

In 2014, the Division of Depositor and

Consumer Protection (DCP) developed a multi-year Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan for the FDIC that

was updated in 2019.

The 2024 Plan is the product of an in-depth process that included an environmental scan, an

assessment of market opportunities and challenges, and lessons learned from the FDIC’s experience

with the most eﬀective approaches to fostering economic inclusion.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan – June 2019 (June 2019).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

State of Economic Inclusion in the United States

The environmental scan generated insights into the state of economic inclusion in the United States

that informed the development of this Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan. Some market trends, such

as a decline in the share of U.S. households that report being unbanked, point to ways in which

economic inclusion in banking has expanded since the Plan was last updated. Other trends, such as

the number and diversity of new nonbank entrants that oﬀer basic financial services, suggest

consumers continue to have fundamental needs not fully addressed by the conventional banking

system.

This section summarizes key findings from the environmental scan and describes trends relevant to

each of the four Opportunity Areas.

The rate of unbanked households has reached historic lows. Over the past decade, the proportion

of unbanked households—those that do not have a checking or savings account—has steadily

declined. The 2021 FDIC Household Survey found that about 4.5 percent of U.S. households are

unbanked, the lowest rate recorded since the survey began in 2009.

Though the decline in unbanked households is undoubtedly a promising trend, the 2021 FDIC

Household Survey highlights continued disparities across demographic groups. Households with lower

incomes and fewer years of formal education are disproportionately likely to be unbanked. The survey

also found that racial disparities in access to bank accounts continued: 2.1 percent of White

households are unbanked, compared to 11.3 percent of Black households, 9.3 percent of Hispanic

households, and 6.9 percent of Native American or Alaska Native households. Other groups

disproportionately represented among unbanked households include working-age households with a

disability and households led by a single parent.

The most common reasons that unbanked households cited in the 2021 FDIC Household Survey for not

having a bank account included not having enough money to meet minimum balance requirements

(cited by 40 percent of unbanked households), concerns about privacy (34 percent), lack of trust in

banks (33 percent), and bank account fees that are too high (29 percent) or unpredictable (27 percent).

A declining proportion of U.S. households are underbanked and rely on nonbank products to

meet basic financial services needs. The 2021 FDIC Household Survey found that 14.1 percent of U.S.

households are underbanked—meaning they have a bank account but use nonbank products or

services to meet some of their basic financial services needs. The rate of underbanked households

varies across demographic groups, following patterns similar to those observed for unbanked

households. More than 20 percent of Black, Hispanic, American Indian, and Alaska Native households

are underbanked, compared to 9.3 percent of White households. As with the unbanked rate, the

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

underbanked rate is higher among lower-income households and households with fewer years of

formal education.

Among underbanked households, 72 percent use nonbank transaction products such as money

orders, check cashing services, and international remittances. Some 18 percent of underbanked

households use nonbank credit products, such as payday loans and auto title loans. The remaining 10

percent or so of underbanked households use nonbank transaction products and nonbank credit

products in combination.

The COVID-19 pandemic aﬀected the financial stability of families and accelerated the adoption

of technology in financial services. The pandemic had a dramatic eﬀect on household finances and

the ways in which households engaged with the financial system.

Many households lost jobs or income during the pandemic. In the 2021 FDIC Household Survey, 29

percent of households reported that someone in their household lost or quit a job, was furloughed, or

had reduced hours; 23 percent reported a significant loss of income since March 2020. Unbanked

households were the most likely to report these types of financial hardships.

The government responded to pandemic-related hardships with increased benefits and stimulus

payments. These government payments, along with declines in household spending, led to an

increase in household savings during the pandemic.

However, the median level of household savings

has since fallen to below 5 percent, a level not seen since 2009.

Falling savings mean that U.S.

households are less able to manage day-to-day expenses and are less able to handle unexpected

expenses, which can have devastating consequences for household financial stability. In 2023, only 63

percent of adults said they could cover a hypothetical $400 expense using cash or cash equivalent and

only 54 percent reported they have three months of emergency savings.

The pandemic underscored the urgency of helping LMI consumers gain access to the banking system.

For consumers eligible to receive economic impact payments, Child Tax Credits, or a tax refund from

the Internal Revenue Service, the FDIC leveraged the #GetBanked

campaign to share information

about how to open a bank account and provide that bank account information to the Internal Revenue

Service. The FDIC also conducted outreach to banks and community-based organizations to enhance

consumer access to financial services that would allow receipt of government payments directly and

safely.

Households also changed how they made payments during the pandemic, with trends persisting aer

its acute phase. The share of transactions made in cash declined from 26 percent in 2019 to 19 percent

Federal Reserve Board, Excess Savings during the COVID-19 Pandemic (October 2022).

Federal Reserve Economic Data, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Personal Saving Rate (July 2023).

Federal Reserve Board, Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2022 – May 2023 (June

2023).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Press Release: FDIC Launches #GetBanked Campaign in Houston and

Atlanta (April 2021)

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

in 2020 and stood at 18 percent in 2022.

In place of cash, consumers increased use of credit and

electronic payments, including digital wallets and online payment accounts. Although the increase in

adoption of online payment accounts was steady in the years leading up to the pandemic, adoption

spiked in the second quarter of 2020.

In 2022, two-thirds of households reported using such

products.

The prospect of pandemic-related government payments (such as unemployment benefits or

pandemic-related stimulus payments) prompted households to open bank accounts, enabling fast and

secure receipt. In 2021, about one-third of recently banked households (34.9 percent) reported that

receiving a government benefit payment contributed to their opening a bank account.

In a 2020

paper published by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, the authors suggested that a desire to

quickly receive pandemic-related transfers could have prompted households to open nonbank

accounts.

Macroeconomic trends make it challenging for LMI and other underserved consumers and

communities to build wealth. Current macroeconomic trends have created a challenging

environment for consumer wealth-building activities. Obstacles to homeownership, a lack of

aﬀordable housing options, and the burden of student loan debt collectively undermine the ability of

many households to achieve financial stability.

Homeownership—a key wealth-building activity and contributor to the intergenerational transfer of

wealth—is out of reach for many households, particularly Black and Hispanic households. Challenges

that prospective homeowners face include high housing prices and rising interest rates. Mortgage

interest rates increased from historic lows in 2021 to more than 7 percent in 2023.

These challenges

are oen compounded for prospective homebuyers of color, who carry high amounts of non-mortgage

debt (including student loans) that make it harder to qualify for a mortgage. Data from the U.S. Census

Bureau show that the homeownership rate for Black households in the second quarter of 2023 (45.7

percent) lags behind the homeownership rate for White households (74.5 percent) by nearly 29

Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco, 2023 Findings from the Diary of Consumer Payment Choice – Cash

(May 2023).

Federal Reserve Board, Developments in Noncash Payments for 2019 and 2020: Findings from the Federal

Reserve Payments Study (January 2022).

Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, 2022 Survey and Diary of Consumer Payment Choice: Summary Results

(2023).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021).

Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, How the COVID-19 Pandemic May Reshape the Digital Payments

Landscape (June 2020).

Freddie Mac, Mortgage Rates (October 2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

points—a gap that is greater now than it was in 1960.

The Hispanic homeownership rate (49.0

percent) also lags far behind the rate for White households.

High rental housing cost burdens also limit opportunities for saving—including saving for a down

payment on a home.

Black households and other households of color are more likely to be renters

than homeowners and tend to have higher rent burdens than their White counterparts. Compared

with 44 percent of White renters, 55 percent of Black renters spend more than 30 percent of their

income on rent and utilities. This leaves little room for saving and investment. The inability to build

home equity through homeownership and limitations on savings related to high housing cost burdens

further compound the racial wealth gap and restrict opportunities for economic advancement.

Another challenge for many consumers is the burden of student loan debt. The cost of higher

education has skyrocketed, leaving a generation of consumers with substantial student loan

obligations. The challenge is magnified and most keenly felt by households that have amassed

student loan debt but who have not obtained a degree or credential that could lead to higher-earning

job opportunities. Among households with student loan debt, Black households have higher average

and median debt levels than do households of other races and ethnicities. For example, in 2019 about

30 percent of Black households had student loans, compared with 20 percent of White households.

This debt load can delay wealth accumulation, as individuals must allocate a significant portion of

their income toward loan repayment instead of saving or investing. For many, the burden of student

loans can hinder their ability to buy a home, start a business, or invest in assets that appreciate. As a

result, the weight of student loan debt can prolong the cycle of financial struggle for low-income

individuals and families, limiting their wealth-building prospects.

Nonbanks expanded their oﬀerings and role in the market. A notable trend since the last update of

the Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan has been the continued expansion of nonbanks and the

introduction of new products that can be used as alternatives to bank products and services. These

nonbank products, including online payment accounts and digital wallets, may provide some of the

functionality oﬀered by traditional checking and savings accounts, such as the ability to receive and

store money,

but may have diﬀerent levels of consumer protection. Similarly, Buy Now Pay Later

U.S. Census Bureau, Quarterly Residential Vacancies and Homeownership, Second Quarter 2023 (August

2023); The Pew Charitable Trusts, Black Families Fall Further Behind on Homeownership (January 2023)

U.S. Census Bureau, Quarterly Residential Vacancies and Homeownership, Second Quarter 2023

(August 2023).

National Low Income Housing Coalition, The Gap: A Shortage of Aﬀordable Homes (March 2023).

Urban Institute, Student Loan Debt and Access to Homeownership for Borrowers of Color (November 2022;

corrected February 2023).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, FDIC Consumer News: Banking with Apps (November 2020).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

loans—which are oﬀered at the point of sale and enable borrowers to pay for a purchase in

installments—provide an alternative to a credit or debit card.

In recent years, the share of mortgages made by nonbank lenders has significantly surpassed the

share originated by bank lenders. In June 2023, nonbank lenders made 79 percent of all mortgages

purchased by government-sponsored enterprises; the share was even higher—93 percent—for

government-backed loans (e.g., Federal Housing Administration and Veterans Administration loans)

that disproportionately are used by first-time homebuyers and lower-income and non-White

borrowers.

Nonbank lenders also provide small business loans and services. In 2022, by some

reports, 24 percent of firms used financing from a financial company that is not a bank.

Recent events highlighted the value of deposit insurance. Crypto assets, such as Bitcoin and

Ethereum, have grown in popularity in recent years, with some proponents touting them as the future

of money. However, many consumers who invested in this market have collectively lost more than $1

billion over the past few years due to price volatility and various scams.

Consumers who fall victim to

scams related to crypto assets oen have limited recourse for recovering their investments. In

response to significant volatility and other vulnerabilities associated with the crypto-asset sector, the

Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System (Federal Reserve), the Oﬀice of the Comptroller of

the Currency (OCC), and the FDIC issued a joint statement that underscored the risks associated with

this sector.

The number of bank failures has fallen dramatically since 2008, with no bank failures recorded in 2021

or 2022. However, in 2023, three banks—with a total asset value exceeding $500 billion—failed in two

months.

The FDIC and other federal regulators reacted swily to protect depositors, maintain

stability and liquidity in the banking sector, and maintain public confidence in the banking system.

This episode reinforced the critical importance of deposit insurance for consumers.

Regulators have developed new rules for banks around community investment. The Federal

Reserve, OCC, and the FDIC provide oversight and support to encourage financial institutions to help

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Consumer Use of Buy Now, Pay Later: Insights from the CFPB Making

Ends Meet Survey (March 2023).

Urban Institute, Housing Finance at a Glance: A Monthly Chartbook (July 2023).

Federal Reserve Banks, 2023 Report on Employer Firms: Findings from the 2022 Small Business Credit Survey

(2023). This paper uses data from the Small Business Credit Survey, which is drawn from a convenience

sample.

Federal Trade Commission, New Analysis Finds Consumers Reported Losing More than $1 Billion in

Cryptocurrency to Scams since 2021 (June 2022).

Financial Institution Letter, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Joint Statement on Crypto-Asset Risks to

Banking Organizations (January 2023).

Martin Gruenberg, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Recent Bank Failures and the Federal Regulatory

Response (March 2023); Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Bank Failures in Brief - Summary 2001

through 2023 (July 2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

meet the credit needs of their entire community, including low- and moderate-income neighborhoods

in which the institution does business to further the purpose of the Community Reinvestment Act

(CRA) of 1977. On October 24, 2023, the agencies issued a unified set of new rules aimed at

strengthening and modernizing CRA regulations by:

• Encouraging banks to expand access to credit, investment, and banking services in LMI

communities;

• Adapting to changes in the banking industry, including mobile and internet banking;

• Providing greater clarity, consistency, and transparency in the application of the regulations;

and

• Tailoring CRA evaluations and data collection to bank size and type.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Community Reinvestment Act (October 2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

External factors can aﬀect progress toward economic inclusion objectives

Many external factors beyond the FDIC’s control may aﬀect progress toward the strategic objectives

described in this Plan. Some of these factors are:

• Economy and financial environment: Changes in economic conditions are diﬀicult to predict yet can

have a significant impact on household finances and banking behavior. As the recent past illustrates,

shis in economic conditions can have positive or negative impacts on economic inclusion prospects. For

example, the U.S. unemployment rate fell from about 15 percent in April 2020 to less than 4 percent in

2022 and 2003,

helping to improve consumer finances. The 2021 FDIC Household Survey suggests that

starting a new job can prompt households to open a bank account.

Conversely, from roughly second

quarter 2021 through first quarter 2023, the United States experienced high inflation that made it more

diﬀicult for some LMI consumers to meet day-to-day and unexpected expenses. Credit became more

expensive, with higher interest rates on many consumer products including mortgages and credit cards.

Many consumers increased their borrowing in response to rising prices.

• Emerging technologies: Rapidly evolving technologies continue to present both potential benefits and

challenges to consumers and banks and aﬀect how consumers and banks interact. On the one hand,

advances in the digital space oﬀer opportunities for banks to serve a broader set of consumers, improve

services, lower operating costs, and enhance customer experiences. On the other hand, emerging

technologies could present risks as banks manage operational and other technology-related

vulnerabilities and adapt compliance management systems. Consumers, especially those who might not

have access to or comfort with technology, could find that some products and services are not as readily

available outside of digital channels. Future technological developments could help expand economic

inclusion for some but could also exclude others. New technologies have supported the growth of

financial services from nonbank providers. A potential issue associated with this development is that

consumers might not be able to distinguish between bank and nonbank providers and could be unaware

of the risks associated with nonbanks (including gaps in consumer protection and regulation).

• Climate change: Climate change presents a variety of risks to the financial health of consumers; these

risks are more acute for LMI and other underserved consumers due to limited financial resources to adapt

and respond to climate-related financial stressors. For example, extreme weather events such as

hurricanes, floods, and wildfires can result in property damage and loss, straining a household’s financial

security and increasing housing insecurity. The FDIC has taken an active role in promoting climate

resilience within the financial sector and has developed a framework to guide financial institutions in

how to prepare for and respond to climate-related financial risks.

• Government actions: Executive, legislative, judicial, and state actions could aﬀect the FDIC’s

achievement of its economic inclusion strategic objectives. In addition, actions taken by other financial

regulators at the federal and state levels could aﬀect the financial regulatory environment and therefore

the success of the FDIC’s Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan strategies. The FDIC will monitor and respond

to these changes, adapting its economic inclusion strategies as needed.

U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Civilian Unemployment Rate (2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Application of Learning from the Environmental Scan

The four economic inclusion Opportunity Areas and associated strategies in this Economic Inclusion

Strategic Plan reflect the insights gained through the environmental scan. For example, the

environmental scan findings led the FDIC to make the following changes to the content and structure

of the previous Plan:

• Focus Opportunity Areas on outcomes. During the environmental scan, stakeholders noted

that the Opportunity Areas in the FDIC’s previous Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan focused

on bank products and services that could be leveraged to foster economic inclusion. Many of

these stakeholders suggested the new Plan focus on desired outcomes for consumers and their

communities, especially LMI and other underserved populations, rather than on products and

services. This led the FDIC to organize the Opportunity Areas in this Plan around outcomes,

rather than bank products. This shi ensures that the strategies in this Plan center on the

advancement of economic inclusion outcomes, including fostering greater access to safe and

aﬀordable products, services, and investments.

• Target and deliver just-in-time financial education. Drawing on lessons from research and

comments made during the environmental scan, the FDIC has integrated financial capability

strategies into each Opportunity Area, rather than having a separate Opportunity Area focused

on financial education. This shi helps to emphasize initiatives and programs that capitalize

on just-in-time financial education when a consumer is most likely to use the knowledge they

gain, such as when opening a bank account or considering whether to buy a home. The

literature suggests that these types of financial education interventions oﬀer advantages over

general classroom-based instruction. The shi also signals that financial education is integral

to all of the FDIC’s eﬀorts to advance economic inclusion, not just one program or product.

• Focus more attention on sustained use of bank accounts. Findings from the environmental

scan underscore the importance of building on the FDIC’s successful eﬀorts to facilitate

opening a bank account to include a greater emphasis on sustaining account use. Sustained

account use helps consumers deepen their banking relationships, with access to a wider range

of safe and aﬀordable products and services. (See Opportunity Area 1. Create and Sustain

Foundational Banking Relationships.)

• Emphasize household financial stability. Results from the environmental scan suggest that

the FDIC should focus more heavily on enhancing consumer financial stability. This can be

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021).

Federal Reserve Bank of Boston, Credit Card Spending and Borrowing Since the Start of the COVID-19

Pandemic (2023).

Financial Institution Letter, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Principles for Climate-Related Financial

Risk Management for Large Financial Institutions (October 2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

accomplished through strategies that help consumers borrow and save in ways that allow

them to better meet both their daily needs and unexpected costs such as health care or car

repair bills. (See Opportunity Area 2. Build Household Financial Stability.)

• Promote wealth-building activities. Results from the environmental scan support the

importance of helping consumers achieve their long-term financial goals by building wealth

and acquiring assets that can accumulate value. (See Opportunity Area 3. Achieve a Secure

Financial Future.)

• Elevate the importance of community development. In the interviews conducted during the

environmental scan, stakeholders highlighted the value of having an Opportunity Area that

explicitly focuses on enhancing community development outcomes, with a particular

emphasis on LMI communities. (See Opportunity Area 4. Live in Strong and Healthy

Communities.)

• Target strategies to reach LMI and other underserved communities. Results from the

environmental scan highlighted the disparities in access to safe and aﬀordable financial

services across subpopulations. These findings, together with guidance from recent Executive

Orders,

emphasize the importance of enhancing economic inclusion among subgroups that

are disproportionately unbanked and underbanked, including Black, Hispanic, and American

Indian or Alaska Native households; working-age households with a disability; and single-

parent households.

The stakeholder interviews conducted as part of the environmental scan informed the strategies in the

Plan by highlighting three key levers the FDIC can use to promote economic inclusion:

• Awareness and education. The FDIC has long been a trusted source of information for

consumers and plays an important role in raising awareness of safe and aﬀordable financial

services. The FDIC oﬀers financial education materials for consumers of all ages and

backgrounds through its Money Smart curriculum, Consumer News publication, and other

resources available on the FDIC website (FDIC.gov

). Stakeholders recommended the FDIC

leverage its experiences and expertise to provide targeted learning opportunities for

consumers using a just-in-time approach, such as when opening a bank account or

considering the purchase of a home. The FDIC also has a valued track record of helping banks

become aware of opportunities to expand economic inclusion, such as participating in federal

government programs designed to broaden the availability of credit. Stakeholders

recommended the FDIC continue to educate and support banks in their eﬀorts to expand

See, for example, Executive Order 13985 (2021), which lays out a policy of developing a whole-of-government

approach to advancing equity for all and includes language that would support eﬀorts by the FDIC to allocate

resources to address historic disinvestment. Also relevant is Executive Order 14031 (2021), which aims to build

on previous policies and help advance equity, justice, and opportunity for Asian Americans, Native Hawaiians,

and Pacific Islanders.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

economic inclusion and meet their regulatory obligations under the Community Reinvestment

Act through technical assistance and education.

In October 2023, the FDIC launched a national deposit insurance awareness campaign about

how it can protect consumers’ money in the event of a bank failure. “Know Your Risk. Protect

Your Money” is a consumer-focused campaign that aims to reach those who may have lower

confidence in the U.S. banking system or who are unbanked, as well as those who use mobile

payment systems, alternative banking services, and financial products that may appear to be

FDIC-insured but are not.

• Partnerships and collaborations. The FDIC cultivates and invests in the development of

extensive national, regional, and local networks of financial institutions; community-based

organizations; and federal, state, and local agencies to identify opportunities to reduce

challenges for consumers, address community-specific challenges, and capitalize on

opportunities to promote economic inclusion. Stakeholders suggested the FDIC continue to

collaborate with existing and new partners to develop coordinated initiatives that meet the

needs of diverse consumers. Stakeholders emphasized that the FDIC should pay particular

attention to building out strategic partnerships that maximize its reach into LMI and other

underserved communities.

• Research and innovation. The FDIC leads research initiatives, such as the FDIC National

Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households, that provide insights into consumers’

changing needs. The FDIC also promotes innovative approaches to economic inclusion in the

banking sector by conducting pilot programs and disseminating promising practices.

Stakeholders emphasized the significant value of the FDIC’s research, which informs

practitioners’ work and contributes to broader research eﬀorts; for example, data from the

FDIC Household Survey are widely used by academics, policy researchers, and other

government agencies in their research and analyses.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Implementation of the Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan

The Division of Depositor and Consumer Protection (DCP) supports the FDIC’s mission to maintain

stability and public confidence in the nation’s financial system by working to advance economic

inclusion, protect consumers, and build positive connections between banks and other stakeholders.

DCP ensures that banks keep their customers’ money safe, treat customers fairly, and operate in

compliance with federal consumer protection, anti-discrimination, and community reinvestment laws.

In addition, DCP builds positive connections among banks, consumers, small businesses, and

communities to promote public confidence.

Two branches in DCP play a particular role in advancing economic inclusion. Through its national and

local partnerships, easy-to-access resources, and expansive stakeholder network, the Consumer and

Community Aﬀairs Branch promotes access to banking services across the country. It comprises the

Community Aﬀairs Program, the Consumer Aﬀairs Program, and the National Center for Consumer and

Depositor Assistance, which includes the Consumer Response Unit and Deposit Insurance Section.

Community Aﬀairs collaborates with bank regulatory agencies, federal agencies, financial institutions,

community-based organizations, and local and state governments to encourage partnerships to help

deliver credit to low- and moderate- income individuals and neighborhoods, inform financial

institutions and community organizations about the availability of public and private development

resources, and promote an understanding of the rights and responsibilities of individuals,

communities, and financial institutions regarding the Community Reinvestment Act and fair lending

laws.

Within Consumer Aﬀairs, the Consumer Education Section provides consumers with resources and

products through social media, online content and interactive games, publications, and more. The

section develops and disseminates Money Smart—the FDIC financial education suite of curricula for all

ages—and provides training to banks, teachers, parents, emerging small businesses, and nonprofit

training organizations.

DCP’s Policy and Research Branch also plays a critical role. Economists, analysts, and other

professionals in the branch develop authoritative data, articles, and reports that help measure and

provide better understanding of consumer participation in the banking system and identify

opportunities to enhance economic inclusion. The branch also conducts analyses to support FDIC

program development, implementation, and assessment. Policy analysts ensure economic inclusion

considerations are evaluated, as appropriate, in various policy processes. They also develop internal

and external guidance that can help clarify the ways in which legal requirements are consistent with,

and support, economic inclusion eﬀorts, such as those associated with the Community Reinvestment

Act.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan Framework

Strategic Goal:

Promote economic inclusion for all U.S. households

Vision Statement:

The FDIC supports economic inclusion by promoting a state in which all U.S. households,

including those in underserved communities, can establish, sustain, and benefit from

banking relationships to create a strong financial foundation, manage their day-to-day

finances, and build wealth and live in communities strengthened by bank lending, services,

and investments.

Opportunity Area Objective

1. Create and Sustain Foundational

Banking Relationships: Establish an on-

ramp to the U.S. financial system, setting

the stage for future financial success

Increase the share of households that establish and

sustain bank accounts, using them as their primary

means to receive income, make payments, and keep

their money safe

2. Build Household Financial Stability:

Help households save and increase access

to consumer credit to better manage

ongoing and emergency expenses

Increase the share of households that have access to

and benefit from banking products and services to

manage fluctuations in income and expenses, such as

variable work earnings and unanticipated expenses

3. Achieve a Secure Financial Future:

Build household wealth through

investments that can foster savings and

accumulate value over time

Increase the share of households that benefit from

banking services and other programs that expand

access to mortgage credit and broaden the

availability of small business financing and services,

particularly to small and very small businesses

4. Live in Strong and Healthy

Communities: Encourage bank lending,

investments, and services that support

strong and healthy communities, including

low- and moderate-income (LMI)

neighborhoods and other underserved

communities

Encourage financing and other resources available to

LMI and other underserved communities from banks

to improve conditions for residents, including

improving community facilities, increasing aﬀordable

housing, and enhancing employment opportunities

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Opportunity Area 1. Create and Sustain Foundational Banking

Relationships: Establish an on-ramp to the U.S. financial system, setting the

stage for future financial success.

Objective: Increase the share of households that establish and sustain bank

accounts, using them as their primary means to receive income, make

payments, and keep their money safe

Monitoring Measures

• 1.A. The share of U.S. households that are unbanked

• 1.B. The share of U.S. households that are underbanked

• 1.C. The share of unbanked U.S. households that express interest in opening a

bank account

• 1.D. The share of U.S. households that are recently unbanked

Motivation

Opening and maintaining a bank account is a fundamentally important step, enabling consumers to

make progress toward achieving their financial goals. Bank accounts provide households with (1) a

safe place to store their money while maintaining easy access to it, (2) the ability to make payments

swily and securely, and (3) tools for monitoring payments and balances. Opening a bank account is

the primary way consumers establish a banking relationship and improve their access to other helpful

financial products they can use to build savings and access credit. Consumers benefiting from a

banking relationship in these ways develop positive associations that cumulatively bolster public

confidence in the U.S. financial system.

The FDIC is committed to helping households establish a strong financial foundation by working to

increase the share of households with safe, secure, and aﬀordable bank accounts that meet their

needs. Though considerable progress has been made in recent years in reducing the share of

unbanked households, the 2021 FDIC Household Survey showed that about 4.5 percent of U.S.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021).

Ibid

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021). The FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households defines “recently

unbanked” households as those not having a bank account at the time of the survey who did, however, have a

bank account at some point in the previous 12 months.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

households still do not have a checking or savings account; among households with a bank account,

14.1 percent also used nonbank financial services to meet their financial needs.

The 2021 FDIC Household Survey also found that lower-income households, households with fewer

years of formal education, Black households, Hispanic households, working-age households with a

disability, and single-parent households, among others, are more likely to be unbanked or

underbanked. These households face multiple challenges to opening and sustaining bank accounts.

The most commonly cited reason is lack of funds to meet minimum balance requirements.

Other

challenges include trust-related concerns, concerns about privacy, high and unpredictable fees, and

challenges related to proximity to and cultural competency of bank branches.

These challenges

could help explain why nearly three-quarters of unbanked households surveyed reported being “not

very” or “not at all” interested in opening an account. Some unbanked households are denied the

opportunity to open an account because they lack commonly accepted identification credentials or

have negative information in systems that banks use to assess a potential customer’s risks.

The

challenges that unbanked and underbanked households face when trying to use banking services can

lead them to use nonbank financial services that can have fewer consumer protections, cost more, and

be less secure or less convenient.

Banks report several challenges to serving unbanked or underbanked consumers, including navigating

legal requirements and the perceived lack of profitability.

In addition, limitations of the systems that

banks use to manage accounts can make it harder for banks to oﬀer innovative new products. Finally,

though some banks have paired products and services that meet the needs of underserved

households with strategies that enable them to attract, serve, and retain customer relationships with

those households, many banks have not yet implemented these strategies fully.

During the pandemic, the FDIC undertook eﬀorts to connect households to safe and secure accounts.

Public awareness campaigns directed at consumers focused on the benefits of opening a bank

account, and events for financial institutions focused on expanding account access. The FDIC is well-

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked

Households (2021).

U.S. Government Accountability Oﬀice, Financial Technology: Products Have Benefits and Risks to

Underserved Consumers, and Regulatory Clarity Is Needed (March 2023); The Aspen Institute, The Price of

Entry: Banking in America (February 2023); and Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, Unbanked in America: A

Review of the Literature (May 2022).

Dennis Campbell, F. Asís Martínez-Jerez, and Peter Tufano, Bouncing Out of the Banking System: An Empirical

Analysis of Involuntary Bank Account Closures (April 2012), note that involuntary account closures have

historically been more frequent in U.S. counties with overall lower education levels, lower wealth levels,

higher unemployment rates, and a larger fraction of single mothers. See also The Aspen Institute, The Price of

Entry: Banking in America (February 2023).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Bank Eﬀorts to Serve Unbanked and Underbanked Consumers

(May 2016).

Ibid

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

positioned to build on these eﬀorts to help spark sustainable relationships between consumers and

banks.

Theory of Change

Figure 3. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 1: Create and Sustain Foundational Banking Relationships

A primary objective of the FDIC’s work in this Opportunity Area is to increase the share of households

that establish and sustain bank accounts, using them as their primary means of conducting their basic

financial aﬀairs. To advance this objective, the FDIC will implement strategies that address challenges

and leverage opportunities for expanding bank account access and use. As reflected in Figure 3, key

challenges for consumers include a lack of trust in the banking system and concerns about

requirements and costs associated with bank accounts. To improve consumer trust in the banking

system, the FDIC will leverage strategic partnerships with trusted organizations that serve the

unbanked and underbanked to raise their awareness about the benefits of safe and aﬀordable

accounts. In particular, the FDIC will seek out partnerships with organizations that serve LMI and other

underserved consumers.

Among other strategies, the FDIC will work with these partners to leverage its Money Smart curriculum

focused on establishing and sustaining bank accounts. These partners will then help raise consumer

awareness and understanding about banking products and services that meet their needs, including

account monitoring tools to help consumers avoid fees and lessen the need for reliance on credit.

Having a greater understanding of the banking products and services available will help consumers

maintain a sense of control over their finances, which will encourage ongoing account use. To

overcome consumer concerns about costs, the FDIC will work to expand the availability of low-cost

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

bank accounts, such as those that align with the Bank On National Standards for certified Bank On

accounts.

The FDIC will also work to increase access to safe and aﬀordable accounts for consumers by engaging

banks. Key challenges for banks to serve unbanked and underbanked households include a

perception that expanding bank account access would increase compliance risk and hinder bank

profitability, as well as technological limitations that prevent banks from innovating. The FDIC will

address these challenges by directly communicating with banks, by reducing perceived challenges to

oﬀering programs and services that meet consumer needs, and by drawing attention to successful

examples. As part of these eﬀorts, the FDIC will leverage its relationships with other regulators, banks,

and trade groups to raise awareness and counter misperceptions about regulatory challenges to

serving LMI and other underserved populations. The agency will highlight and promote safe and

secure products and services that meet the needs of these consumers.

The FDIC will also seek partnerships with relevant agencies and organizations to connect consumers

to safe and aﬀordable accounts, leveraging program-specific “bankable moments,” such as the FDIC’s

partnership with the Internal Revenue Service that encouraged consumers to open safe and secure

accounts to receive economic stimulus payments during the pandemic. In addition, the FDIC will

explore collaborations with other federal agencies to develop guidance for banks that support

reducing challenges to account access.

The FDIC’s eﬀorts will be informed by research it leads related to account opening and use, including

the biennial FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and Underbanked Households, which collects data that

will continually inform how strategies are targeted and implemented.

Strategies

Awareness and Education

1.1 Raise awareness of and interest in establishing and using accounts through direct

communications with consumers by the FDIC and partners that serve LMI and other underserved

consumers.

1.2 Raise awareness and interest among banks, particularly community banks, in oﬀering safe and

aﬀordable accounts (such as Bank On certified accounts), with no overdra or insuﬀicient funds

fees, other low-cost features, and features facilitating broad functionality, accessibility, and

availability.

The FDIC developed the Model Safe Account Template in 2012; Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, FDIC

Model Safe Accounts Template (2012). The Bank On National Standards incorporated the core principles

outlined in the template; Martin Gruenberg, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Bank On/Cities for

Financial Empowerment National Launch of Account Standards (2015).

The FDIC will continually monitor the needs among underserved populations and adjust its work to address

emerging or changing needs.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

1.3 Encourage banks to make safe and aﬀordable accounts readily available in all channels,

including branches, and to develop strategies promoting them eﬀectively to consumers,

including by prominently featuring them on bank websites and in marketing materials.

1.4 Identify organizations that work with unbanked and underbanked households and train them on

Money Smart materials on establishing and sustaining bank accounts. Focus training eﬀorts on

organizations that serve LMI and other underserved populations.

1.5 Educate banks on the opportunity for CRA consideration, including with respect to digital and

other delivery systems that respond to the needs of LMI consumers.

Partnerships and Collaborations

1.6 Develop partnerships with relevant agencies and other organizations to connect consumers to

safe and aﬀordable accounts, leveraging program-specific “bankable moments” that capitalize

on consumers’ interest in receiving payments swily and securely.

1.7 Encourage core service providers to adapt their systems to enable banks to easily oﬀer safe and

aﬀordable accounts (such as Bank On certified accounts) with no overdra or insuﬀicient funds

fees and with other features that enhance functionality, accessibility, and inclusive access.

1.8 Identify potential opportunities to work with other banking agencies, the Consumer Financial

Protection Bureau, and other relevant stakeholders to address actual or perceived challenges to

opening accounts.

Research and Innovation

1.9 Conduct research to measure consumer participation in the banking system, assess bank eﬀorts

to serve unbanked and underbanked populations, and better identify challenges to account

opening and sustained use, clarifying the conditions under which various challenges are most

prominent.

1.10 Identify and assess promising approaches that expand account access and sustained use of

banking services. Highlight eﬀective programs to banks, trade groups, community networks, and

other stakeholders.

Key Performance Indicators

Awareness and Education

• Number of communications about bank account access and use sent to consumers by the

FDIC and its partners; percentage of consumers who engaged with the information as

measured by impressions and unique visits to websites linked to the communications;

percentage who reported that the information was valuable.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

• Number of stakeholders (and market share of banks) that participate in FDIC training and

outreach related to account opening and use; share of these partners reporting intent to take

action aer engaging with the FDIC.

• Number and market share of banks reporting they are more interested in oﬀering certified or

other responsive accounts aer an FDIC engagement.

• Share of households that felt more confident in their ability to establish and maintain a

banking relationship aer participating in a program oﬀering Money Smart.

Partnerships and Collaborations

• Number of banks that oﬀer Bank On certified or other responsive accounts; share of U.S.

households in markets served by a bank that oﬀers such accounts.

• Number of unique visits to web pages that include materials created or promoted by the FDIC

and shared as part of an FDIC outreach communication initiative; share of web page visitors

who reported that the information was valuable.

• Number of engagements (e.g., events and meetings) with community-based organizations in

which Community Aﬀairs personnel provide resources related to safe and aﬀordable bank

accounts; number of follow-up engagements with these community organizations related to

addressing challenges in bank account access.

Research and Innovation

• Number of presentations made to banks, trade groups, community networks, and other

stakeholders about promising approaches that expand account access and sustained use of

banking services; share of attendees that report finding this information useful.

• Number of research articles and reports from the FDIC and other sources related to bank

accounts, banking relationships, and consumer payments citing FDIC economic inclusion

research or data.

• Number of unique visits to FDIC web pages that feature economic inclusion research, data, and

related information; share of web page visitors who report finding the information valuable.

• Number of readers and other consumers of popular media reporting on FDIC economic

inclusion research or data.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Opportunity Area 2. Build Household Financial Stability: Help households

save and increase access to consumer credit to better manage ongoing and

emergency expenses.

Objective: Increase the share of households that have access to and benefit

from banking products and services to manage fluctuations in income and

expenses, such as variable work earnings and unanticipated expenses.

Monitoring Measures

• 2.A. The share of households with a dedicated savings account.

• 2.B. The share of adults who say they can cover a $400 expense using cash or cash

equivalent

• 2.C. The share of households with a credit score

• 2.D. The share of households with a prime credit score

Motivation

Access to savings or other liquid financial resources enables consumers to better handle both regular

expenses and financial shocks or unexpected expenses, such as a sudden medical bill or car repair or a

period of unemployment. Without these resources, it can be diﬀicult for consumers—especially LMI

consumers—to meet their immediate needs and maintain the financial stability that serves as a

foundation for realizing longer-term financial goals. Banking products such as savings accounts,

credit-building products, and small-dollar credit options can help families build and access liquid

resources to meet their day-to-day needs and manage financial ups and downs.

The FDIC is committed to promoting broad availability of accessible savings and aﬀordable credit from

banks and to helping households understand the benefits of and gain access to such products to help

them be better prepared to meet their needs and manage unexpected expenses.

Federal Reserve Board, 2019 Survey of Consumer Finances (2019).

Federal Reserve Board, Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2022 (May 2023).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, How America Banks: Household Use of Banking and Financial

Services (2019).

There are a number of diﬀerent ways to determine the share of households with a prime credit score. For

example, the Financial Health Network’s Financial Health Pulse 2022 U.S. Trends Report (September 2022)

notes the share of consumers that report having a prime credit score. Periodic reports from commercial credit

bureaus also note the share of consumers with a prime credit score. If needed, the FDIC might consider

purchasing data from one or more credit bureaus to assess this monitoring measure or partnering with

another federal agency that has access to these data.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Many households do not have enough savings to draw on to manage unexpected expenses. In 2023,

only 63 percent of adults said they could cover a hypothetical $400 expense using cash or cash

equivalent and only 54 percent reported they have three months of emergency savings.

For many

LMI and other underserved consumers, limited cash flow is a key impediment to saving, including

building emergency savings.

Low- and no-fee transaction and savings accounts with low or no

minimum balance requirements that allow easy access to funds are particularly important for

consumers trying to build an emergency fund. Features such as automatic deposits and matched

savings programs can help facilitate regular contributions by consumers so they can build savings over

time. In addition, products or services oﬀered when the consumer has money to save, such as when

they receive a tax refund, public benefit, or a raise at work, are an opportunity for consumers to

contribute to their savings.

Small-dollar credit products, such as safe and aﬀordable consumer loans, or credit cards can also help

households manage expenses. Some consumer credit products can be costly, and many less costly

options require applicants to have an established positive credit score. However, about one-fih of

households likely do not include a member with a credit score.

Low-income, young, Black, and

Hispanic consumers are among those most likely to lack a credit score.

Some bank representatives cite diﬀiculties ascertaining the creditworthiness of LMI potential

borrowers as a challenge to lending to these households.

Banks most oen use traditional

underwriting practices to determine borrower creditworthiness. These practices increase the

likelihood that borrowers with low—or no—credit score are rejected. However, technological

developments have made it easier to analyze financial transaction data from bank accounts. Using

certain information rarely found in credit reports could help banks evaluate the creditworthiness of

consumers who might not obtain credit using traditional underwriting standards.

Other approaches,

such as making credit products available to established customers in good standing, leveraging

automation and partnerships to lower the cost of acquisition and delivery, and designing programs

that support consumer repayment, can also expand the number of consumers who qualify.

Federal Reserve Board, Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S. Households in 2022 (May 2023).

The Aspen Institute, Short-Term Financial Stability: A Foundation for Security and Well-Being (April 2019).

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Building a Brighter Future by Saving at Tax Time (October 2018); and

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Planning for Tax-Time Savings: Innovation Insights (September 2019).

A number of eﬀorts have been undertaken to encourage consumers to apply for refundable tax credits, such

as the Earned Income Tax Credit and the Child Tax Credit. Building on these eﬀorts could provide an

opportunity for the FDIC to facilitate partnerships to help LMI and other underserved households increase

savings.

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, How America Banks: Household Use of Banking and Financial

Services (2019).

Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Data Point: Credit Invisibles (2015).

Lawrence J. White, The Community Reinvestment Act at 40: Why Is It Still Necessary to Lean on Banks? (2020).

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Interagency Statement on the Use of Alternative Data in Credit

Underwriting (2019).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

The FDIC is well-positioned to encourage banks to develop savings and credit products that can help

families manage financial ups and downs aﬀordably. Over the years, the FDIC has helped households

build savings and access small-dollar loans by developing Money Smart resources related to savings

strategies; supporting national and regional initiatives, such as America Saves; and conducting

research about safe small-dollar loans. For example, the FDIC facilitates the Youth Banking Network,

which consists of 85 banks, by supporting bank eﬀorts to engage and educate youth across the

country and connect them with savings accounts.

Theory of Change

Figure 4. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 2: Build Household Financial Stability

To improve household financial stability, the FDIC will implement strategies that address the

challenges that inhibit LMI and other underserved consumers from saving and accessing consumer

credit. As reflected in Figure 4, key challenges that aﬀect the ability of consumers to save and access

credit include a lack of cash flow available for savings, a lack of eﬀective engagement with products

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

and programs that support savings, no or a low credit score (which inhibits access to credit), a lack of

responsive credit products, and limited awareness of products and services that meet their needs.

To facilitate savings by consumers with limited incomes, the FDIC will facilitate programmatic

partnerships between banks and community-based organizations and government agencies that

administer programs that provide opportunities to save. This could include initiatives that help

consumers access additional funds, such as from tax refunds (e.g., those who receive the Earned

Income Tax Credit

or the Child Tax Credit) or from guaranteed income programs. The FDIC will

identify and build strategic partnerships with community-based organizations to help consumers

capitalize on times when they have income they can save and take advantage of other strategies that

support savings behavior. Further, the FDIC will facilitate partnerships between these organizations

and banks to foster consumer savings in safe and aﬀordable accounts. To help consumers gain access

to credit, the FDIC will continue to encourage banks to oﬀer products that help consumers build their

credit scores, such as credit-builder loans or secured credit cards. The FDIC will raise consumer

awareness of products and services through partnerships with organizations whose clients include

unbanked and underbanked consumers. The FDIC will encourage these partners to oﬀer its Money

Smart curriculum focused on savings and building credit.

The FDIC will seek to address the lack of products and services by educating and building awareness

among banks about promising approaches to oﬀering credit-building and responsible small-dollar

lending products. This could include, for example, the potential to use deposit account data in the

underwriting process and engaging with core service providers

and others with a role in enabling

banks to oﬀer such products.

The FDIC’s work in this area will be informed by FDIC research on promising practices for overcoming

challenges and capitalizing on opportunities related to consumer savings and credit, with a focus on

the experiences and perceptions of LMI and other underserved households.

Strategies

Awareness and Education

2.1 Identify partners that work with unbanked and underbanked consumers, including youth and

young adults, and train them to use Money Smart materials to expand awareness and

understanding of the benefits of building savings and promising strategies for doing so.

Internal Revenue Service, EITC Participation Rate by States Tax Years 2012 through 2019 (2022). Many

households eligible for the Earned Income Tax Credit do not claim it. In tax year 2019, 79.3 percent of eligible

residents nationally claimed the credit, though participation rates varied by state. Eﬀorts that aim to increase

the share of eligible households that claim the tax credit could complement tax-time savings eﬀorts.

Core service providers are the companies that oﬀer soware and technology solutions to financial

institutions, primarily banks, to manage their core banking functions and operations.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

2.2 Identify partners that work with unbanked and underbanked consumers, including LMI and other

underserved consumers, and train them to use Money Smart materials to build awareness and

understanding of the benefits of building a positive credit history and score and promising

strategies for doing so.

2.3 Raise awareness of opportunities to build savings and positive credit history through

communications and resources for consumers and partners that serve LMI and other underserved

consumers.

2.4 Engage community organizations and their members to assess their needs, increase awareness of

the FDIC and other resources related to savings and credit.

2.5 Expand awareness among banks of promising approaches to oﬀering credit products that help

LMI and other underserved households establish a positive credit history, such as credit-builder

loans or secured credit cards.

2.6 Expand awareness among banks of promising approaches to oﬀering safe and aﬀordable credit

products that help LMI and other underserved consumers address cash fluctuations, such as

responsible small-dollar loans.

Partnerships and Collaborations

2.7 Partner with federal, state, and local government benefit programs to identify opportunities to

help LMI and other underserved households save. Facilitate partnerships between these

programs and banks to help LMI and other underserved households increase savings.

2.8 Partner with community-based organizations and nonprofit financial counseling agencies to

cross-promote resources related to credit building and to gain an understanding of the credit

needs of consumers.

Research and Innovation

2.9 Conduct research to measure consumer use of bank and nonbank credit and savings products;

conduct research to understand banks’ provision of products and programs to meet the savings

and credit needs of a wide range of consumers and obstacles to consumers’ ability to access and

benefit from them.

Key Performance Indicators

Awareness and Education

• Number of households reached through Money Smart materials focusing on savings; share of

users reporting more understanding of and interest in savings.

This information may come from outreach events, listening sessions, or formal research.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

• Number of households reached through Money Smart materials focusing on credit building;

share of users reporting more understanding of and interest in credit building.

• Number of households sent direct communications from the FDIC or a partner; percentage

who engaged with the information as measured by impressions and unique visits to websites

linked to the communications; share who reported that the information was valuable.

• Number and market share of institutions that oﬀer responsible credit-building products, such

as credit-builder loans or secured credit cards; share of U.S. households served by a bank that

oﬀers credit-building products.

• Number and market share of institutions that oﬀer responsible small-dollar credit products,

such as aﬀordable small-dollar loans; share of U.S. households served by a bank that oﬀers

safe, aﬀordable short-term credit products, such as aﬀordable small-dollar loans.

Partnerships and Collaborations

• Number and market share of institutions that partner with community-based or government

programs that help LMI and other underserved populations save.

• Number of stakeholders that participate in FDIC training and outreach on maximizing

opportunities to save; percentage reporting intent to take action aer engaging with the FDIC;

number of households served by those partners or institutions.

• Number of partners that participate in FDIC training and outreach related to credit building;

percentage reporting intent to take action aer engaging with the FDIC; number of households

served by those partners or institutions.

Research and Innovation

• Number of research articles and reports from the FDIC and other sources related to consumer

credit, credit scores, credit building, or savings citing FDIC economic inclusion research or

data.

• Number of unique visits to FDIC web pages that feature economic inclusion research, data, and

related information on credit or savings; share of web page visitors who report finding the

information valuable.

• Number of readers and other consumers of popular media reporting on FDIC economic

inclusion research or data related to credit or savings.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Opportunity Area 3. Achieve a Secure Financial Future: Build household

wealth through investments that can foster savings and accumulate value

over time.

Objective: Increase the share of households that benefit from banking

services and other programs that expand access to mortgage credit and

broaden the availability of small business financing and services, particularly

to small and very small businesses.

Monitoring Measures

• 3.A. The share of small businesses that receive credit from banks

• 3.B. The share of banks’ home purchase lending to low- or moderate-income

borrowers and to borrowers in low- and moderate-income areas.

Motivation

Building household wealth is an important part of promoting consumer financial stability, well-being,

and future opportunities, including the opportunity for intergenerational wealth transfer. Though a

range of wealth-building activities help consumers work toward long-term financial stability, including

building retirement savings and accessing education loans, this Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan

focuses the FDIC’s eﬀorts on homeownership and small business ownership. These are areas where

banks can play an important role and where the FDIC is well-positioned to support their work. Buying

a house or starting a business requires long-term planning and preparation. To meet these financial

goals, consumers need access to safe and aﬀordable financial products that facilitate wealth building

and access to long-term credit.

The FDIC is committed to improving consumer access to banking resources needed to become a

homeowner or start or grow a business, including aﬀordable mortgages and small business loans.

These investments will help consumers build long-term savings and assets and make progress toward

financial security. When banks provide mortgages and small business services and loans, confidence

increases that the products will be well-suited to the needs of consumers and will likely benefit them

over the long term.

• Homeownership. Owning a home can help households build home equity—a significant

source of household wealth, including wealth that can be passed on to the next generation.

Homeowners build home equity through both “forced savings” (a portion of each monthly

payment on an amortizing mortgage contributes to home equity) and home value

appreciation (gain when the value of the home exceeds its original purchase price).

Federal Reserve Board, Availability of Credit to Small Businesses (October 2022).

Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council, The Home Mortgage Disclosure Act (June 2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Homeownership is also supported by several public policies, including the tax code, which can

bolster household balance sheets.

In 2020, the median wealth of homeowners—comprising mostly home equity—exceeded that

of renters by $330,372, or 58 percent.

However, homeownership may be out of reach for

many households. In 2023, two-fihs (40 percent) of all renters reported they cannot qualify

for a mortgage and 65 percent said they cannot aﬀord the down payment for a home.

Homeownership aﬀordability has also declined in recent years as home prices and interest

rates have risen.

Studies have underscored the importance of not just attaining

homeownership, but sustaining homeownership over time. In one study, low- and moderate-

income households that sustained homeownership had more than 20 times the wealth of

similarly situated households that remained renters.

Homeownership rates vary significantly

by race and ethnicity. In the second quarter of 2023, more than 74 percent of White non-

Hispanic households owned their home, compared to 46 percent of Black households, 49

percent of Hispanic households (of any race), and 58 percent of other households of color.

Current market conditions underscore the need for programs and services to proactively meet

the needs of LMI and other historically underserved communities. Current housing prices—

combined with mortgage rates that are at a 20-year high as of 2023—require consumers to pay

a large share of their income for housing. In June 2023, the share of median income needed for

the average monthly mortgage payment was 33.9 percent.

Given these costs, it is not

surprising that the share of purchase mortgages going to LMI homebuyers has declined—from

39.4 percent in 2018 to 23.1 percent in 2022.

Over the past decade, nonbanks have played a growing role in the mortgage market. In June

2023, nonbank lenders made 79 percent of all mortgages purchased by government-

sponsored enterprises. The share was even higher—93 percent—for government-backed loans

(e.g., Federal Housing Administration and Veterans Administration loans) that

disproportionately are used by first-time homebuyers and lower-income and non-White

borrowers.

However, banks continue to have a meaningful role to play in the mortgage

Donald Hays and Briana Sullivan, The Wealth of Households: 2020, U.S. Census Bureau (August 2022).

Federal Reserve Board, Supplemental Appendixes to the Report on the Economic Well-Being of U.S.

Households in 2022 (May 2023).

Urban Institute, Housing Finance at a Glance: A Monthly Chartbook (July 2023).

Freeman, A. and R.G. Quercia. 2014. Low and Moderate-Income Homeownership and Wealth Creation. UNC

Center for Community Capital Working Paper. Chapel Hill, NC: UNC Center for Community Capital.

U.S. Census Bureau, Quarterly Residential Vacancies and Homeownership, Second Quarter 2023 (August

2023).

Urban Institute, Housing Finance at a Glance: A Monthly Chartbook (July 2023).

Ibid

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

market. From an economic inclusion standpoint, fostering consumer use of aﬀordable

mortgage products and increasing bank participation in mortgage lending remain important.

Business Ownership. Building a business can provide additional financial stability that helps

business owners increase their income over time and generate wealth that can be passed on to

the next generation. In addition, providing loans and grants to diverse entrepreneurs is seen

by many as an important way to address the racial wealth gap.

Small business loans provide

business owners with the capital needed to start, expand, or improve their businesses. For

example, research shows that loans of less than $50,000—or microloans—are the financing

product that will reach the greatest number of Black and Hispanic/Latino entrepreneurs.

However, accessing credit can be challenging. Only about 15 percent of small businesses

applied for credit in 2020; just 60 percent received the amount requested, and 12 percent

received none. Trends in Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) lending suggest that lending in

historically underserved areas, including LMI and rural areas, is lower than for urban, higher-

income areas.

72,73

Community development financial institutions (CDFIs) have long been a

source of support for businesses in LMI communities and those businesses with owners of

color who have lacked access to traditional sources of capital and small business support.

Banks, especially community banks, play a unique role as service providers to and financers of

small businesses in their areas and are important participants in the Small Business

Administration–guaranteed 7(a) loan program. Small business loans oen represent a majority

of community banks’ commercial and industrial portfolios. Community banks have a locally-

minded focus and emphasize relationship building that allow them to be key supporters of

small businesses in their area. Leveraging practices and competencies that meet the specific

contexts of entrepreneurs who face barriers to accessing credit due to a range of factors, such

as diﬀerences in cultural experiences and languages, low levels of wealth, or thin or no credit

files, can enable community banks to more successfully reach the full range of creditworthy

entrepreneurs.

Taken together, the trends in homeownership and business ownership underscore the importance of

ensuring that consumers, particularly LMI and other underserved consumers, are aware of and have

access to programs and services available to them on their wealth-building journeys. By facilitating

The Aspen Institute, Scaling Lending to Entrepreneurs of Color: Part I (November 2021).

Ibid

U.S. Small Business Administration, Paycheck Protection Program (May 2021). For example, 28 percent of

approved PPP loans were in LMI areas, and 16.6 percent of approved PPP loans were in rural areas.

Federal Reserve Board, Availability of Credit to Small Businesses (November 2022).

The Aspen Institute, Scaling Lending to Entrepreneurs of Color: Part I (November 2021).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

wealth building and access to long-term credit, banks can help LMI and other underserved

populations build a secure financial future.

The FDIC is well-positioned to grow its eﬀorts to support consumer wealth building through

homeownership and small business ownership. For example, the FDIC’s online Aﬀordable Mortgage

Lending Center, which provides information to banks and promotes responsible, aﬀordable mortgage

lending, has more than 54,800 subscribers.

On the small business lending front, the FDIC is a trusted

resource, facilitator, and connector. For example, Money Smart for Small Business and the practitioner

network of training providers within the Money Smart Alliance are established resources that the FDIC

can leverage to support the financial goals of aspiring entrepreneurs. The FDIC has networks that

include a well-established partnership with the Small Business Administration (SBA) and relationships

with trusted community partners, including SBA’s Small Business Development Centers, Women’s

Business Centers, Veteran Outreach Centers, and others.

Theory of Change

Figure 5. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 3: Achieve a Secure Financial Future

As of August 2023.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

To support consumers’ journeys toward long-term financial security, the FDIC will implement a suite of

strategies that address the key challenges to consumer access to banking products and services that

support homeownership and business ownership and growth.

As reflected in Figure 5, consumers

face multiple challenges to accessing homeownership and business ownership and growth, including

insuﬀicient savings for a down payment or to seed a small business, high levels of debt, low incomes,

and low credit scores. Some entrepreneurs lack awareness of processes and the capacity to fulfill

requirements to establish a small business and apply for resources available through loans or

technical assistance programs. Consumers also could be unaware of programs that can help them

overcome these challenges, such as down payment assistance or technical assistance for small

businesses. To build consumer awareness and increase use of these resources, the FDIC will partner

with intermediaries, including community-based organizations that oﬀer financial resources,

education, and technical assistance. To promote the uptake of these opportunities, the FDIC will

facilitate strategic partnerships between community-based organizations and banks.

For banks, key challenges to engaging in mortgage and small business lending for LMI and other

underserved populations include perceived complexity, risk, and lack of profitability. For mortgages

specifically, some banks have withdrawn their participation in federally sponsored mortgage

programs and others have never participated.

To counter these challenges, the FDIC will work with

banks and other relevant stakeholders to raise awareness and interest in promising approaches such

as government-backed guarantee programs, down payment assistance, and Special Purpose Credit

programs.

The FDIC’s work in this area will be informed by ongoing FDIC research on promising practices related

to supporting small business ownership and homeownership. This work will include conducting and

disseminating information about promising approaches and products.

Strategies

Awareness and Education

3.1 Educate banks about community-based and government programs that promote

homeownership among LMI and other underserved consumers (including down payment

assistance programs, public housing agency programs that support homeownership, and

homebuyer education and counseling programs).

The environmental scan conducted as part of the strategic planning process informed this approach; rather

than having separate opportunity areas for business lending and mortgages, the FDIC will focus on fostering

bank-related activities that promote long-term financial stability, including activities that promote ownership

of homes and small businesses.

Following the passage of new regulations aer the 2008 financial crisis, most mortgages follow product

parameters that conform to those laid out by the government-sponsored enterprises (GSEs) Fannie Mae and

Freddie Mac.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

3.2 Educate banks about community-based and government programs that support aspiring

entrepreneurs (such as capital access and technical assistance programs).

3.3 Identify organizations that work with residents of LMI and other underserved communities and

educate them about government and bank products and programs that support aspiring

homebuyers and small business owners.

3.4 Identify partners that work with LMI consumers and train them to use Money Smart materials that

address home buying and homeownership.

3.5 Support organizations that provide training and technical assistance using the Money Smart

financial education program to build awareness of how entrepreneurs can start and run their

small business and how to access and apply for resources to support it.

3.6 Educate and raise awareness among organizations that work with LMI and other underserved

entrepreneurs about promising strategies to help small businesses active in LMI neighborhoods

make informed choices about credit options, particularly given gaps in regulatory protections

that may result, for example, in them receiving less fulsome disclosures.

3.7 Educate and raise awareness among banks about promising approaches to developing Special

Purpose Credit programs and other products to help LMI consumers access capital for

homeownership and small business ownership.

3.8 Educate and raise awareness among banks about promising approaches to developing products

that support LMI homeowners to maintain or make renovations or modifications needed to stay

in their homes.

Partnerships and Collaborations

3.9 Develop strategic partnerships with organizations and government agencies that support

homeownership and small businesses; identify gaps (in knowledge, resources, etc.) and

opportunities for collaboration.

3.10 Encourage banks to partner with federal, state, and local government programs and programs

oﬀered by nonprofit organizations that help LMI and other underserved consumers access down

payment funds or homebuyer/owner education and counseling services.

3.11 Facilitate collaboration between community banks and small business technical assistance

providers to support consumers in their pursuit of small business financing.

Research and Innovation

3.12 Stay current on leading research; conduct research and analyze available data to inform FDIC

program development and implementation, including trends in bank residential mortgage

lending and lending to businesses, including very small businesses, woman- and minority-owned

small businesses, and other business segments identified as underserved.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Key Performance Indicators

Awareness and Education

• Number of unique visits to FDIC online resources about mortgages and small business lending;

percentage of visitors who reported that the information was valuable.

• Number of banks and community-based organizations trained on teaching Money Smart for

Small Business; percentage of those trained that report feeling more confident in helping

small businesses aer they attended the training.

• Number of consumers reached through Money Smart materials focusing on homeownership

and business ownership.

o Share of users reporting a better understanding of the homebuying process and the

steps required to obtain a mortgage.

o Share of users reporting increased confidence managing small business finances.

• Number of community-based organizations, small business owners, and entrepreneurs that

attend FDIC-led education that helps small businesses active in LMI neighborhoods make

informed choices about credit options; percentage of attendees reporting increased

confidence to make informed choices about credit options; number of households served by

those organizations.

• Number and market share of banks that attend FDIC-led education related to developing

Special Purpose Credit programs and other products to help LMI consumers access capital for

homeownership and small business ownership; percentage and market share reporting intent

to take action aer engaging with the FDIC; number of households served by those partners or

institutions.

• Number of banks that attend FDIC-led education related to promising approaches to

developing products that support LMI homeowners to maintain and/or make renovations or

modifications needed to stay in their homes; percentage and market share reporting intent to

take action aer engaging with the FDIC; number of households served by those banks.

Partnerships and Collaborations

• Number of banks that attend FDIC partnership-oriented engagements related to small

business and homeownership programs; percentage that report making new contacts;

percentage and market share reporting intent to take action aer engaging with the FDIC.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Opportunity Area 4. Live in Strong and Healthy Communities: Encourage

bank lending, investments, and services that support strong and healthy

communities, including low- and moderate-income (LMI) neighborhoods and

other underserved communities.

Objective: Encourage financing and other resources available to LMI and

other underserved communities from banks to improve conditions for

residents, including improving community facilities, increasing aﬀordable

housing, and enhancing employment opportunities.

Monitoring Measures

• 4.A. Dollar amount of community development lending by CRA reporters

• 4.B. Share of CRA reporters that report community development lending

Motivation

For more than a century, a wide range of partners have worked to reduce poverty and improve living

conditions and quality of life in LMI neighborhoods across the United States. In the modern era, these

eﬀorts have focused on developing quality, aﬀordable, and mixed-income housing; investing in small

businesses that provide jobs and services in these neighborhoods; encouraging and supporting

investments by banks and other financial institutions to provide the capital needed to strengthen

communities; and engaging community residents, organizations, and businesses as partners in the

community development process. Key community development partners include community

development corporations and other community-based nonprofit organizations that build housing,

improve streetscapes, provide essential services, and advocate for stronger policies and funding;

anchor institutions like universities and hospitals that provide jobs, local leadership, and financial

support; local governments that administer federal and state programs and provide vital social

services; and banks and community development financial institutions (CDFIs) that provide capital for

housing, small businesses, and other community needs.

Today’s community development eﬀorts are supported by federal policies and programs that work

collectively to improve local conditions. These include the Low-Income Housing Tax Credit, which has

Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council, CRA National Aggregate Table 3: Community Development

Lending (2021). CRA reporters are institutions that have CRA obligations; they include national banks, savings

associations, and state-chartered commercial and savings banks that are FDIC insured.

Ibid

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

produced or preserved more than 3.5 million aﬀordable rental units,

and the New Markets Tax Credit,

which, through the end of fiscal year 2021, had, “supported the construction of 76.9 million square feet

of manufacturing space, 118.3 million square feet of oﬀice space, and 77.1 million square feet of retail

space” and helped create or retain more than 938,000 jobs.

A third key federal support for

community development eﬀorts is the CDFI Fund that provides funding and technical assistance to

CDFIs that in turn support small businesses, aﬀordable housing, and other community needs. Among

the many other federal programs that support community development eﬀorts are the Community

Development Block Grant and aﬀordable housing programs administered by the U.S. Department of

Housing and Urban Development and the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Rural Housing Service.

Another key federal policy supporting community development is the CRA, which encourages banks to

provide services, lend, and invest in the communities in which they do business, including LMI

communities, consistent with safe and sound operations. The FDIC is one of three federal regulators

responsible for implementing the CRA. In this role, the FDIC assesses the extent to which banks fulfill

their CRA obligations. The CRA plays an important part in expanding the availability of credit and

banking services in LMI and other underserved communities, critically helping to ensure that banks

are actively engaged in community development eﬀorts.

Bank engagement with LMI individuals and in LMI and other underserved communities can result in

substantial social, economic, and environmental benefits. For example, according to community

development lending data reported by large banks, in 2021, banks made more than $151 million in

community development loans that are eligible for CRA credit, benefiting such individuals and

communities.

Since 1996, certain large financial institutions have been mandated to report their

community development loans. These reports indicate notable increases in aﬀordable housing

lending, with substantial increases in the construction and preservation of new housing units. Beyond

housing, bank community development loans and investments have also expanded the number of

community facilities and fostered the establishment of new businesses and job opportunities.

Despite these various programs and CRA’s positive impact on community development outcomes,

LMI neighborhoods still fall short on measures of community health and well-being such as access to

health care, safe and aﬀordable housing, and employment opportunities. The FDIC is well-positioned

U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, Low-Income Housing Tax Credit (LIHTC): Property Level

Data (2023).

Community Development Financial Institutions Fund, Fact Sheet: New Markets Tax Credit Program (2022).

Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council, Findings from Analysis of Nationwide Summary Statistics

for 2021 Community Reinvestment Act Data Fact Sheet (2022).

Panagiotis Avramidis, George Pennacchi, Konstantinos Serfes, and Kejia Wu, The Role of Regulation and Bank

Competition in Small Firm Financing: Evidence from the Community Reinvestment Act (April 2022); Lei Ding

and Carolina K. Reid, The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) and Bank Branching Patterns (September

2019); and Lei Ding and Leonard I. Nakamura, “Don't Know What You Got Till It’s Gone”—The Community

Reinvestment Act in a Changing Financial Landscape (February 2020).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

to encourage and support community development loans, services, and investments that benefit LMI

communities. The FDIC hosts regular meetings across the country where banks and community-based

organizations meet to discuss local challenges and pursue promising solutions. In addition, in 2023,

the FDIC and the other two federal regulators with responsibility for the CRA finalized a regulation that

strengthens and modernizes CRA.

This Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan signals the FDIC’s commitment to continuing to encourage

banks to direct their resources in ways that support all the communities in which they operate.

Theory of Change

Figure 6. Theory of Change for Opportunity Area 4: Live in Strong and Healthy Communities

The strategies that the FDIC implements in this Opportunity Area will result in growth in bank loans,

investments, and services that are responsive and contribute to positive community development

Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Interagency Overview of the Community Reinvestment Act Final Rule

(October 2023).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

outcomes, including greater access to aﬀordable health care, aﬀordable housing, and employment for

community residents.

As shown in Figure 6, many community stakeholders are not aware of the types of bank loans,

investments, and services that may qualify as community development for CRA purposes. The FDIC

will build partnerships and networks with nonprofit and government programs that raise awareness

about opportunities to access loans and investments that may qualify under CRA. In addition, the FDIC

will bring together local and regional nonprofit organizations and private and public sector

stakeholders to find areas of alignment across community development needs and available

resources. These networks of stakeholders will be better equipped to partner with banks to leverage

investments in community infrastructure that improves community health and well-being.

Some banks, especially community banks, would be better positioned to meet the needs of their

community by increasing their awareness of community development needs and models of

community development financing that have been implemented successfully elsewhere. To improve

bank knowledge of and interest in investing in LMI communities, the FDIC will educate banks about

opportunities for CRA-qualified lending activities, including promising approaches that leverage

private, government, and philanthropic investments. The FDIC expects that this awareness will lead

banks to explore and pursue activities that are CRA-qualified and benefit communities. The FDIC will

also raise awareness among banks about opportunities to achieve community development

objectives through investments in financial institutions that are located in and serve LMI communities,

including minority depository institutions (MDIs), women depository institutions (WDIs), low-income

credit unions (LICUs), and CDFIs.

The FDIC’s work in this area will be informed by ongoing FDIC research that identifies and elevates

successful strategies for banks to invest in building and maintaining aﬀordable housing and essential

community facilities and infrastructure, promising practices for bank engagement and outreach to LMI

communities, and opportunities for bank investments that leverage government-sponsored

community development programs and initiatives.

Strategies

Awareness and Education

4.1 Educate and inform banks about opportunities for CRA-qualified community development

lending, investment, and service activities, including opportunities that support aﬀordable

housing, economic development, community support services, community revitalization, and

essential community facilities and infrastructure.

4.2 Facilitate meetings and forums that bring together banks, community development practitioners,

and other relevant public and private sector stakeholders to explore community needs and

identify how CRA-qualified investment opportunities can meet those needs.

4.3 Educate and build awareness among community-based organizations about opportunities to work

with banks to increase CRA-qualified lending and investment that support community needs.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Partnerships and Collaborations

4.4 Encourage bank activities that support MDIs, WDIs, LICUs, and CDFIs to expand their reach in LMI

communities, including in rural areas.

4.5 Facilitate collaborations among banks and federal, state, local, and tribal government agencies;

CDFIs; and other stakeholders to identify initiatives, opportunities, and promising practices to

achieve local community development goals; share learning to encourage replication of promising

approaches and identify gaps where further policy development eﬀorts are needed.

Research and Innovation

4.6 Stay current on research related to community development needs and approaches; conduct

research and analyze available data to inform FDIC program development and implementation

related to bank involvement in community development eﬀorts, such as investments in aﬀordable

housing, economic development, community support services, community revitalization, and

essential community facilities and infrastructure.

Key Performance Indicators

Awareness and Education

• Number and market share of banks that participate in FDIC training and outreach related to CRA-

qualified community development activities; percentage and market share of those banks

reporting intent to take action aer engaging with the FDIC.

Partnerships and Collaborations

• Number and market share of banks that receive information from the FDIC about promising

practices for community engagement and outreach by banks; percentage and market share of

banks that attend FDIC partnership-oriented engagements and report making new contacts.

• Number of attendees at engagements with federal, state, and local stakeholders that explore how

banks can address community development outcomes; percentage of and market share of bank

attendees reporting intent to take action aerward.

Research and Innovation

• Number of unique visits to FDIC web pages that include publications and resources related to the

role of banks in community development; percentage of those visitors who report finding the

information valuable.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

Appendices

Appendix A: Overview of Environmental Scan Process........................................................... A-1

Appendix B: Research Questions and Associated Literature Sources from the

Environmental Scan ............................................................................................................ B-1

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

A-1

Appendix A: Overview of Environmental Scan Process

The FDIC draed this Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan according to applicable requirements of the

Government Performance and Results Act of 1993 (GPRA), as amended, the GPRA Modernization Act of

2010, and OMB Circular A-11. The FDIC is also developing internal processes to facilitate monitoring

and evaluating the four strategic objectives outlined in this Plan.

The strategic planning process for this Plan included an in-depth environmental scan comprising two

streams of research activities: (1) a literature review and (2) internal and external stakeholder

interviews and listening sessions. The insights from that research informed the development of the

Opportunity Areas, objectives, and strategies in this Plan.

Seven research questions guided the literature review. The review also included a summary of

relevant executive orders and other relevant literature that emerged during the environmental scan.

Appendix B lists the research questions guiding the literature review and the sources reviewed, which

included peer-reviewed articles, white papers, and FDIC internal documents.

The stakeholder listening sessions involved 19 FDIC stakeholders and 39 external stakeholders

including researchers, practitioners, career staﬀ from other federal agencies, and staﬀ from financial

institutions and nonprofit organizations.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-1

Appendix B: Research Questions and Associated Literature Sources

from the Environmental Scan

The environmental scan included a literature review guided by seven research questions. The review

also included relevant executive orders and other relevant literature that emerged during the scan.

1. What kinds of activities were included in the FDIC’s current Economic Strategic

Inclusion Plan, and what did the FDIC accomplish? (Summarize key activities,

accomplishments, barriers and challenges, and opportunities)

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2019). Economic Inclusion Strategic Plan.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2007). A Longitudinal Evaluation of the Intermediate-

term Impact of the Money Smart Financial Education Curriculum upon Consumers’ Behavior

and Confidence.

2. What is the broader research landscape saying about successes and

challenges/barriers in getting the unbanked and underbanked banked nationally?

• Boel, P. & Zimmerman, P. (2022). Unbanked in America: A Review of the Literature. Economic

Commentary 2022-07. Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland.

• Burhouse, S., Navarro, B., Osaki, Y. (2016). Opportunities for Mobile Financial Services to

Engage Underserved Consumers: Qualitative Research Findings. Federal Deposit Insurance

Corporation.

• Elmi, S., Kohli, S., and Lopez, B. (2023). The Price of Entry: Banking in America. Aspen Institute.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2022). 2021 FDIC National Survey of Unbanked and

Underbanked Households. https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/2021report.pdf

• Government Accountability Oﬀice. (2023). Financial Technology: Products have Benefits and

Risks to Underserved Consumers, and Regulatory Clarity is Needed. (GAO 23-105536.)

• Hayashi, F., & Minhas, S. (2018). Who Are the Unbanked? Characteristics Beyond Income.

Economic Review, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, 103(2), 55-70.

• National Federation of Community Development Credit Unions. (2016). Beyond Financial

Access: Striving for Deeper Immigrant Financial Inclusion (p. 52). National Federation of

Community Development Credit Unions.

http://www.inclusiv.org/wp-

content/uploads/2017/07/Federation_Immigration-Report_r4_WEB_singlepages.pdf.

• White, L. (2020). The Community Reinvestment Act at 40: Why Is It Still Necessary to Lean on

Banks? Housing Policy Debate, 30(1), 110-115. https://doi.org/10.1080/10511482.2019.1665832.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-2

3. What does the literature say about how banks respond to the Community

Reinvestment Act?

• Avramidis, P., Pennacchi, G., Serfes, K., Wu, K. (2022). The Role of Regulation and Bank

Competition in Small Firm Financing: Evidence from the Community Reinvestment Act.

Journal of Money, Credit and Banking, 54(8), 2301-2340. https://doi.org/10.1111/jmcb.12938

• Ding, L., & Nakamura, L. (2021). “Don't Know What You Got till It’s Gone”: The Community

Reinvestment Act in a Changing Financial Landscape. Journal of Real Estate Research, 43(1),

96-122.

• Ding, L., & Reid, C. K. (2020). The Community Reinvestment Act (CRA) and Bank Branching

Patterns. Housing Policy Debate, 30(1), 27-45.

• Long, M. (2020). Informal Borrowers and Financial Exclusion: The Invisible Unbanked at the

Intersections of Race and Gender. The Review of Black Political Economy 47(4), 363-403.

• White, L. (2020). The Community Reinvestment Act at 40: Why Is It Still Necessary to Lean on

Banks? Housing Policy Debate, 30(1), 110-115. https://doi.org/10.1080/10511482.2019.1665832

• Zuluaga, D., & Forrester, A. C. (2020). The Impact of the Community Reinvestment Act on

Neighborhood Gentrification. Quarterly Journal of Finance & Accounting, 58(3).

4. Is financial education eﬀective? How eﬀective is financial education broadly in

changing consumer behavior? What do we know about the eﬀicacy of financial education

in getting the unbanked and underbanked banked?

• Al-Bahrani, A., Weathers, J., & Patel, D. (2019). Racial Diﬀerences in the Returns to Financial

Literacy Education. The Journal of Consumer Aﬀairs, 53(2), 572-599. doi:10.1111/joca.12205.

• Davis, H., & Hasler, A. (2021). Testing the Use of the Mint App in an Interactive Personal Finance

Module. Global Financial Literacy Excellence Center.

https://gflec.org/wp-

content/uploads/2021/02/Mint-Report-Final-Version-February-10-2021.pdf?x73402.

• Elliott, D., Theodos, B., Teles, D., Adaeze, O., & Docter B. (2020). An Evaluation of the $tand By

Me® Financial Coaching Program. Urban Institute.

https://www.urban.org/sites/default/files/publication/103036/an-evaluation-of-the-tand-by-

me-financial-coaching-program_0.pdf.

• Kaiser, T., & Menkhoﬀ, L. (2017). Does Financial Education Impact Financial Literacy and

Financial Behavior, and If So, When? (DIW Berlin Discussion Paper No. 1562). German Institute

for Economic Research. http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2753510

• Kaiser, T., Lusardi, A., Menkhoﬀ, L., & Urban, C. J. (2021). Financial Education Aﬀects Financial

Knowledge and Downstream Behaviors. Journal of Financial Economics.

https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jfineco.2021.09.022

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-3

• Kim, K. T., & Xiao, J. (2020). Racial/Ethnic Diﬀerences in Consumer Financial Capability: The

Role of Financial Education. International Journal of Consumer Studies, 45, 379-395.

https://doi.org/10.1111/ijcs.12628

• Langholz, K., & Selby, C. (2019). Promoting Financial Empowerment Through Building Native

Communities: Financial Skills for Families. Oweesta. https://www.oweesta.org/wp-

content/uploads/2019/10/Oweesta-Key-Bank-Report-2019-Digital-Edition.pdf.

• Pense, R. G. (2021). The Impact of Financial Education on the Lives of Cherokee Nation

Citizens. Dissertation, Walden University, College of Management and Technology.

• Short, K. J. (2020). “Knowledge is Power”: The Eﬀect of Peer-Led Financial Education on

Financial Stress among Graduate Students. University of Georgia, Department of Financial

Planning, Housing and Consumer Economics.

https://esploro.libs.uga.edu/esploro/outputs/9949365653202959

• Walker, J. T., Bocian, D. G., DeMarco, D. & Freeman, B. (2018). Understanding the Pathways to

Financial Well-Being. Abt Associates. https://www.abtassociates.com/sites/default/files/2018-

09/FWB%20Report%202_Final_180709.pdf.

• Wagner, J., & Walstad, W. B. (2019). The Eﬀects of Financial Education on Short-Term and Long-

Term Financial Behaviors. The Journal of Consumer Aﬀairs, 53, 234-259.

doi:10.1111/joca.12210.

5. What are promising practices, strategies, or products being used to help LMI families

build savings?

• Ain, J., Iwry, J. M., Newville, D. (2018). Saving for Now & Saving for Later: Rainy Day Savings

Accounts to Boost Low-Wage Workers’ Financial Security. Prosperity Now.

• Aspen Institute. (2019). Short-Term Financial Stability: A Foundation for Security and Well-

Being. Aspen Institute Financial Security Program.

• Azzolini, D., McKernan, S. M., & Martinchek, K. (2020). Households with Low Incomes Can Save:

Evidence and Lessons from Matched Savings Programs in the US and Italy. Urban Institute.

• Cohen, P., Landry, S., Grober-Morrow, M., Ivila, I., and Chan, P. (2020). Saving for Now, Soon and

Later: How Savings Products Can Better Meet the Needs of Low- to Middle-Income Individuals.

Prosperity Now & Prudential Foundation.

• Cohen, P., Landry, S., & Sueiro, S. (2019). Part One: The Savings Crisis and the Need for Holistic

Solutions. Prosperity Now.

• Commonwealth. (2020). Emergency Savings Features that Work for Employees Earning Low to

Moderate Incomes. Commonwealth and Defined Contribution Institutional Investment

Association (DCIIA).

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-4

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. (2019). Planning for Tax-Time Savings: Innovation

Insights.

• Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, Oﬀice of Community Aﬀairs. (2018). Building a Brighter

Future by Saving at Tax Time.

• Commonwealth & SaverLife. (2022). Accounting for Emergencies: Low- to Moderate-Income

Household Perceptions on the Relationship between Emergency Savings and Retirement

Savings. Commonwealth.

• Dunn, A., & Johnson, H. (2022). Building Consumer Savings with Fintech Innovations Savings

Are a Critical Component of Financial Health, and New Approaches Can Encourage Consumer

Savings. Financial Health Network.

https://finhealthnetwork.org/wp-

content/uploads/2022/07/Building-Consumer-Savings-with-Fintech-Innovations-2022.pdf.

• Johnson, H. & Celik, N. (2021). Targeting Small-Dollar Savings Suggestions to Low-Balance

Customers. Financial Health Network.

• Landry, S. (2019). Part Two: Savings Solutions. Prosperity Now.

• Landry, S. (2019). Part Three: Savings Solutions Features. Prosperity Now.

• Landry, S. (2019). Part Four: Consumer Experience of Savings Solutions. Prosperity Now.

• McKay, K. (2021). Eight Truths about Savings and Four Principles for Inclusion. Aspen Institute

Financial Security Program.

• Sueiro, S., & Cohen, P. (2019). Part Five: Delivering Savings Solutions. Prosperity Now.

6. What small-dollar loan pilots are identified in the literature, and what barriers or

challenges do they face?

• Bank of America. Balance Assist® Can Help with Unexpected Expenses.

https://promotions.bankofamerica.com/deposits/balance-assist.

• Bank of America. (2021). Bank of America SafeBalance Banking Surpasses Three Million Client

Accounts; New Balance Assist Oﬀering to Surpass 100,000 Loans in Less Than a Year.

https://newsroom.bankofamerica.com/content/newsroom/press-releases/2021/09/bank-of-

america-safebalance-banking-surpasses-three-million-clie.html.

• Financial Health Network. (2020). Industry Insights: How Financial Institutions Can Structure

Small-Dollar Credit for Financial Health. Financial Health Network.

• Hahn, H., Quakenbush, C., Martincheck, K., McKernan, S., Sarver, S. (2020). Employer-

Sponsored Small-Dollar Loans. Urban Institute.

• Huntington. Standby Cash. https://www.huntington.com/Personal/checking/standby-cash

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-5

• Huntington Bancshares Inc. (2021). Huntington Launches Standby Cash(SM) to Give Eligible

Customers an Instant Line of Credit for Unexpected Expenses.

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-rel

eases/huntington-launches-standby-cashsm-to-give-

eligible-customers-an-instant-line-of-credit-for-unexpected-expenses-301302362.html.

• Sutaria, N., Townsend Kiernan, K., Miller, S. (2022). Partnerships between Community

Development Financial Institutions and Workforce Development Organizations. Federal

Reserve Bank of Atlanta.

• Veling, J. (2023). Wells Fargo Flex Loan: 2023 Review.

7. What promising practices and strategies are financial institutions (including banks,

nonprofits, and fintech companies) using to engage underserved consumers outside of

account opening?

• Balyuk, T. (2023). FinTech Lending and Bank Credit Access for Consumers. Management

Science 69(1):555-575.

• Cornelli, G., Frost, J., Gambacorta, L., Jagtiani, J. (2022). The Impact of Fintech Lending on

Credit Access for U.S. Small Businesses. (BIS Working Papers No 1041).

• Di Maggio, M., Ratnadiwakara, D., Carmichael, D. (2022). Invisible Primes: Fintech Lending with

Alternative Data. (National Bureau of Economic Research Working Paper 29840).

• Government Accountability Oﬀice. (2023). Financial Technology: Products Have Benefits and

Risks to Underserved Consumers, and Regulatory Clarity Is Needed. (GAO-23-105536).

• Payments Dive. (2020). PrimaHealth Credit Launches ‘Buy Now, Pay Later’ Solution for credit-

Challenged Patients. Industry Dive.

https://www.paymentsdive.com/ex/mpt/news/primahealth-credit-launches-buy-now-pay-

later-solution-for-credit-challenged-patients/?.

Relevant Executive Orders

• Exec. Order No. 13985, 86 Fed. Reg. 14 (January 20, 2021).

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/01/25/2021-01753/advancing-racial-equity-

and-support-for-underserved-communities-through-the-federal-government

• Exec. Order No. 14031, 86 Fed. Reg. 105 (May 28, 2021).

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/06/03/2021-11792/advancing-equity-

justice-and-opportunity-for-asian-americans-native-hawaiians-and-pacific-islanders

• Exec. Order No. 14045, 86 Fed. Reg. 177 (September 13, 2021).

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/09/16/2021-20165/white-house-initiative-

on-advancing-educational-equity-excellence-and-economic-opportunity-for

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-6

• Exec. Order No. 14049, 86 Fed. Reg. 196 (October 11, 2021).

https://www.federalregister.gov/do

cuments/2021/10/14/2021-22588/white-house-initiative-

on-advancing-educational-equity-excellence-and-economic-opportunity-for

• Exec. Order No. 14050, 86 Fed. Reg. 202 (October 19, 2021).

https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2021/10/22/2021-23224/white-house-initiative-

on-advancing-educational-equity-excellence-and-economic-opportunity-for-black

Other Relevant Literature

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). #GetBanked. Retrieved April 24, 2023, from

https://www.fdic.gov/getbanked/.

• Accion Venture Lab. (2020, November 18). Win from Within: How Fintech Startups Can Grow by

Building Value for Existing Users. https://www.accion.org/win-from-within-how-fintech-

startups-can-grow-by-building-value-for-existing-users.

• Aspen Institute. (2020). The Cycle of Savings: What We Gain When We Understand Savings as a

Dynamic Process. Aspen Institute Financial Security Program.

https://www.aspeninstitute.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/09/The-Cycle-of-Savings.pdf

• Barcellos, S., & Zamarro, G. (2021). Unbanked Status and Use of Alternative Financial Services

among Minority Populations. Journal of Pension Economics and Finance, 20, 468-481.

doi:10.1017/S1474747219000052.

• Calem, P., Lambie-Hanson, L. & Wachter, S. (2019). Is the Community Reinvestment Act Still

Relevant to Mortgage Lending? Housing Policy Debate 30(1), 46-60. doi:10.2139/ssrn.3445415.

• Chen, Z., & Friedline, T. (2022). Make the Invisible Underbanked Visible: Who Are the

Underbanked? Journal of Financial Counseling and Planning, 33(2), 160-170. doi:10.1891/JFCP-

2021-0046.

• Congressional Research Service. (2022, July 29). Big Tech in Financial Services.

https://crsreports.congress.gov/product/pdf/R/R47104/3

• Di Maggio, M., Ma, A., Williams, E. (2020). In the Red: Overdras, Payday Lending and the

Underbanked. National Bureau of Economic Research. (Working Paper 28242).

http://www.nber.org/papers/w28242

• Dlugosz, J., Melzer, B., & Morgan, D. P. (2021, June 1). Who Pays the Price? Overdra Fee

Ceilings and the Unbanked. Federal Reserve Bank of New York Staﬀ Report, (973).

https://www.newyorkfed.org/research/staﬀ_reports/sr973.html

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). Aﬀordable Mortgage Lending Center: Federal

Agencies and Government Sponsored Enterprises Programs & Products. Retrieved April 24,

2023, from

https://www.fdic.gov/resources/bankers/aﬀordable-mortgage-lending-

center/products.html.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-7

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). Bankers Resource Center: Aﬀordable Mortgage

Lending Center. Retrieved April 24, 2023, from

https://www.fdic.gov/resources/bankers/aﬀordable-m

ortgage-lending-center/index.html

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2017). Creating Youth Savings Programs in Your

Community. Retrieved April 4, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/youth-

banking-resource-center/documents/ys-roadmap.pdf.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2022). Executive Summary: 2021 FDIC National Survey

of Unbanked and Underbanked Households. Retrieved April 13, 2023, from

https://www.fdic.gov/analysis/household-survey/2021report.pdf

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation.(2023, February 27). FDIC Money Smart Resources.

Retrieved April 13, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/money-

smart/index.html.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). FDIC Money Smart Resources: How Money

Smart Are You? Retrieved April 23, 2023, from https://playmoneysmart.fdic.gov/games.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). FDIC Money Smart Resources: Learn Money

Smart. Retrieved April 24, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/money-

smart/learn-money-smart/index.html.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). FDIC Money Smart Resources: Teach Money

Smart. Retrieved April 23, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/money-

smart/teach-money-smart/index.html.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2022, October 11). FDIC Youth Banking Resource

Center. Retrieved April 13, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/youth-

banking-resource-center/index.html.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2021, March 19). FDIC Youth Banking Resource Center:

The Promise of Youth Savings Programs. Retrieved April 13, 2023, from

https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/youth-banking-resource-center/the-promise-of-

youth-savings-programs.html.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). FDIC Youth Employment Resource Center.

Retrieved April 24, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/youth-employment-

resource-center/index.html.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (2017). Guide to Organizing Reality Fairs. Retrieved

April 4, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/resources/consumers/money-smart/organizing-

reality-fairs/documents/guide-to-organizing-reality-fairs.pdf.

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). Inclusion: Alliance for Economic Inclusion.

Retrieved April 24, 2023, from https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/community/aei/.

ECONOMIC INCLUSION STRATEGIC PLAN

B-8

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (2019). Minutes from the Advisory Committee on

Economic Inclusion, 2019-10

-22. Retrieved from https://www.fdic.gov/about/advisory-

committees/economic-inclusion/2019/2019-10-22-minutes.pdf

• Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation. (n.d.). Welcome to the FDIC Knowledge Center.

Retrieved April 23, 2023, from https://ask.fdic.gov/fdicinformationandsupportcenter/s/public-

information?language=en_US.

• Long, M. (2020). Informal Borrowers and Financial Exclusion: The Invisible Unbanked at the

Intersections of Race and Gender. The Review of Black Political Economy, 47(4), 363-403.

doi:10.1177/0034644620938620.

• Rengert, K., & Rhine, S. (2016). Bank Eﬀorts to Serve Unbanked and Underbanked Consumers:

Qualitative Research. Federal Deposit Insurance Company.

https://www.fdic.gov/consumers/community/research/qualitativeresearch_may2016.pdf

• Toh, Y.L. (2022). Promoting Payment Inclusion in the United States. Payment System Research

Briefing. Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City.

https://www.kansascityfed.org/research/payments-system-research-briefings/promoting-

payment-inclusion-in-the-united-states/.

• Xu, X. (2019). The Underbanked Phenomena. Journal of Financial Economic Policy, 11(3), 385-

404. doi:10.1108/JFEP-09-2018-0125.